Peter G (sinetimore) wrote,
Peter G

The Whole Shooting Match

(Full disclosure:  I don't like guns myself, but I support the right to bear arms.  I'm not one of those "ban the guns" types, because the people buying and using guns legally are not (usually) the ones I have to worry about, so banning guns just seems like punishing the people playing fair while the cheaters continue to carry on.  Admittedly, in this instance, there was nothing that could be done, as the shooter bought his guns legally.  But I don't think eradicating guns from the country is the answer to the problem.)

On Thursday night, in Lafayette, LA, a gunman walked into a movie theater and opened fire.  He killed two people and injured nine others before killing himself.

On Friday morning at work, one of my loudmouth dipshit co-workers began talking.

And repeating the same old song.  "If someone in that theater had a gun, they could have stopped him!  What's the point of concealed carry if you aren't going to use it?!?"

I keep hearing this same thing every time there is a national tragedy.  It's the "What if?" writ large.  The idea that random tragedy can somehow be controlled, that we humans are somehow ultimately in control of the world and our lives and we can make a difference.

But we don't.  We can't.  People who don't deserve success and recognition, who are driven by ego, who treat those below them like dirt, are worshipped as gods (every time I see someone talk with reverence about Steve Jobs, I want to punch someone).  Meanwhile, people with ability, with talent, with humility, those that can make the world a better place, are ignored or exploited as a resource and never allowed to be more than what people want them to be.  In movies, books, song, we hear that we can make it if we try, that lack of effort is the only obstacle to being a success.  Try being a writer for a couple of decades, and see how long it takes before hearing that makes you want to funnel sulfuric acid through your ears.

We live in dangerous times, in a society that has been trained to find any reason to hate and put down and is now practicing it on any target they can find, and responding to any criticism or detraction not with consideration but with singular dismissal -- "Oh, they're just haters.  Your behavior is just fine, and if they liked you, they'd see you as just being you instead of acting like an entitled snot."  We have done such a good job of teaching ourselves to not see other people as people but just obstacles to our self-fulfillment that we no longer accord them any empathy.  We are building a society of narcissistic psychotics, who see nothing wrong with a random act of violence.  In this case, both the shooter and the guy I work with who wants to arm the citizens.  Both want violence visited on favored targets, the only difference is what makes those targets favored.  Killing for the right reasons, that's the excuse.

I pinched the bridge of my nose when I heard this.  Like I said, we don't want to admit we are at the mercy of a cruel world and random chance, so we seek something, anything, that enables us to say, "This could have been prevented, we could have asserted our authority over Fate."  And this line of reasoning, arming all citizens, pops up every time there is a random public massacre, that the bar scene in Chuck Norris' Code Of Silence can be made real.  I heard it after the planes were hijacked on 9/11.  I heard it after Columbine.  After the Aurora Theater shooting.  After Sandy Hook.  And in the days after the shooting of Gabrielle Giffords, I heard it again, but as validation instead of wish fulfillment.  I will get to Giffords in a moment, because it ties in with the point I wish to make.

Feeling weary, I turned to my co-worker and told him, That wouldn't have changed anything.  It would have made it worse.

"No, it wouldn't have!"

First of all, this is Lafayette, Louisiana.  I can guarantee you at least one person in that theater was strapped.

"So why didn't he shoot back?"

Because he knew it was dangerous.  Think about it:  a gunman walks into a darkened theater and starts shooting.  You have to pull your attention aware from the movie, override flight response, stand up from your seat, draw your weapon, get into position, and somehow hit a target in a dark environment without hitting any of the panicking people running for their lives.  You have a better chance of wounding or killing an innocent person than you do hitting the gunman.

"If everybody in that theater was armed, there would have been SOMEONE with a clear shot."

It's not as simple as giving someone a gun, though.  They have to be trained.  They have to know what to do and when to do it.  And some people just don't have it in them to control themselves.  Otherwise, no one coming back from Iraq would have PTSD.

That statement illustrates the point I want to circle back to about the Giffords shooting.  When the gunman opened fire, several of the people in the crowd coordinated and apprehended the gunman.  But this isn't inborn behavior.  It's not something people just know how to do.  The culture of Arizona is frontier country, where guns are just tools and a part of everyday life, where how to handle them and how to take action without being mistaken for another target gets drilled into you at an early age.  You will NOT get this same behavior in, say, New York.  You cannot use the Giffords shooting as an absolute guide for human behavior.

Like I said, there wasn't anything that could be done here.  This wasn't someone who bought the guns illegally or anything like that.  As far as anyone knew, he was just fine.  Under the current system, there was no reason to suspect anything.  And you can't really change the system without negatively impacting the law-abiding citizens who like their guns and are responsible people.

It was a cold, cruel, uncontrolable world.

Whose graveyard we keep trying to whistle by.

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded